Monday, November 23, 2015

Taking Carrot and Stick to Executive Compensation

As noted in the previous post, greedy CEOs place their own financial interests above those of the companies they are responsible for and the needs of their workers.

And boards of directors, seemingly accustomed to such executive palm-geasing in their own organizations, look the other way, or cover their behinds by pointing to so-called so-called “compensation consultants” (also overpaid).

So here are the results of some thinking that followed the composition of the previous post.…

I recommended that CEOs and top executives (including college football coaches, university presidents and executives of non-profits) be compensated at a rate no more than five times the compensation of the average worker in their organization. (Note: Executive compensation - pay and benefits - can't be used to compute the average.)

Right now in this country among large institutions, the ratio is, shamefully, on the order of 300 to one.

The proposal also addresses the complaint about “high corporate taxes.” IF the top officers cut their compensation as described, I suggest that current taxes on their corporations be frozen (or possibly even lowered...see below.)

As noted in my previous post if the average compensation for employees is $50k, under this proposal, the higher-ups in the executive suite would get no more than $250k.

Because they are so smart, the executives should be able to manage on 250 grand a year. Rumor has it that quite a few folks do.

If the executives want to raise their compensation, they can so it by raising the compensation of employees. A $10,000 raise to the average employee, raises executive compensation $50,000.

Still not a lot by current executive pay standards, but that’s the point!

Now the flip side. If the corporations and their board do NOT make these changes, the corporate tax rate gets doubled (or made high enough to provide the "stick" to stop to the greed). Call this the "greed is bad" tax.

In short, fair and reasonable pay is rewarded; greed is punished. “Compensation consultants” are shown the door.

Those with sharp pencils might even be able to show that compensation fairness would actually increase tax revenues, if it encourages raising pay for all. The more the average worker makes the higher the total tax revenues from them. The amount might even bring in more revenue than now, even accounting for the “loss” resulting from lower taxes paid by reasonably paid executives.

If the new law results in significantly more tax revenue, the proposal just might allow for an actual reduction in corporate taxes.

Finally, higher paid workers will presumably buy more, which creates more jobs and more tax revenues. It also helps the economy…to say nothing of employee moral. The list of benefits is long.

One item on it might even be the postponement of the revolution, perhaps indefinitely.

Labels: ,

Saturday, November 21, 2015

Include executive compensation in corporate tax stories

Whenever reporters write of corporate executives' complaints about  high corporate taxes, editors should require them to include the executives’ annual compensation…just to put things in perspective.

One of the biggest  “taxes” around comes through exorbitant executive compensation. The big salaries and benefits tax shareholders and ultimately middle-class taxpayers.

How happy these executives are to boost our taxes to pay for their compensation. Those taxes have gone up and up and up as executives are paid more.

Executive compensation is a business tax write-off. In short, Lithia’s taxes to the state are lower as  it pays its executives more.

And the higher the write-off and executive compensation, the more we taxpayers pay to make up for it.

On today’s Oregonian front page, we have one John North, the chief financial officer of Ashland-based Lithia Moters, complaining that a proposed higher state corporate tax would drive Lithia and other "low margin" businesses out of the state. That, of course, would cost jobs here etc.

In the same story, we have Ken Thrasher, a former Fred Meyer CEO, quoted to similar effect. Groceries are also considered "low-margin."

Question: What is Mr. Thrashers, retirement package from Fred Meyer? What is it compared to that of a checker at Fred Meyer? What does the current CEO at Fred Meyer make? Could Freddie's margins be made less "low" if executives were paid less?

Question: What is Mr. North’s own salary, particularly compared to those who work on the floor or the backshops in Lithia’s dealerships. What is the compensation for Mr. North’s own boss and other top executives?

Part of the solution to the tax-revenue problem is that executive compensation above a set amount shouldn’t be allowed as a tax write off. In that way, corporate taxes would be “raised” and shareholders would presumably benefit.

Or if corporations still want the compensation write off, they should compensate workers more, in part addressing the pressing problem of gross pay inequity in corporate America.

A ratio of executive salary to the pay of the average worker could be set in law. Something like five-to-one. Nationally, the ratio now is something like 300 to 1.

Suppose the average worker at Lithia makes $50,000. Under a new law, Mr. North and others in the executive suite would not be able to make more than $250,000.

With their financial know-how, executives should manage to get by on that.

Could you? Could I?

Labels: , , ,

Monday, November 16, 2015

MODA: a local case study in exorbitant executive compensation

Any CEO who accepts or demands exorbitant compensation, particularly in comparison to the compensation of the company's line workers, should be considered unfit to lead.

Such grotesque inequitable compensation should be outlawed.

Consider the case here in Portland of the publicly-supported Oregon Health Sciences University (OHSU), its questionable financial dealings with the private MODA Health Plan and the compensation of MODA CEO Robert Gootee.

A little background:

The Oregonian reported on Nov. 6 that OHSU lent MODA Health Plan, $50 million at the end of last year. Suffice to say that the two institutions do a lot of business together.

So much so that MODA, according to OHSU officials, is yet another one of those private institutions “too big to fail.” And so the public’s subsidy money gets shoveled to MODA, via OHSU.

It turns out that if MODA does fail, we, fellow taxpayer take the hit. OHSU, Portland’s largest employer, is really, REALLY too big to fail.

OHSU’s board of directors approved the loan last December. A month after the vote, OHSU president Joe Robertson joined MODA’s board. He was paid $26,000 for his services, according to the Oregonian, before leaving the board in two months ago, when MODA’s most recent financial problems came to light.

The paper also reported that Robertson donated his MODA fees to OHSU. One wonders what the money will be used for. Part of another loan to MODA perhaps?

The Oregonian story is long at 36 paragraphs. But it’s not until paragraph 30 that we find out that in 2013 MODA’s CEO Robert Gootee was paid $13 million. Of that $8.9 million was a “one-time” payment for “a terminated retirement plan and deferred compensation he has not yet received.” But in 2012, Gootee received $10.4 million 2012.

Why didn’t Gootee simply drop his shameful compensation to help MODA financially?

The Oregonian apparently didn't ask for an explanation or was refused one, but reporter Jeff Manning does write, “OHSU, meanwhile, still collects millions of dollars a year from Oregon taxpayers. Last spring, weeks after the MODA loan, the Oregon Legislature approved another $270 million for the institution,” which is a public corporation.

The lead to this story could easily have been: “Oregon taxpayers helped OHSU lend health insurance company MODA $50 million last year, one year after, MODA paid its CEO $13 million.”

Kudos to The Oregonian and Manning for revealing the the taxpayer-backed loan, but a juicy rotten tomato for not spotlighting Gootee compensation package…and delving into the question of conflicts of interest and a culture in which executive compensation and greed come first.

Footnote: The MODA in question is the same outfit that has slapped its name on what was once “The Rose Garden." The cost of the glitzy naming rights has been put at $40 million over 10 years.

MODA officials say the number is too high but won’t disclose what it is.

One wonders why....

Update: Today it was reported that OHSU will convert its $50 million loan into a a 25 percent stake in MODA Health Plan.  Question: what will it pay the "new" MODA's CEO?

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, February 19, 2014

The Neediest and The Greediest

Earlier this week a friend drew my attention to a New York Times Sunday edition story about the results of the paper’s end-of-the-year “Neediest Cases Fund” drive.

The friend’s adult child had a hand in raising $77,000 at her place of employment, the financial giant Citigroup.

The entire, laudable Times campaign effort raised nearly $6 million for the “neediest” in the New York City. The Times story, in addition to devoting four paragraphs to Citigroup’s contribution, detailed the plight of several served by the fund.

It happens that I read this heart-warming story just as I’ve been reading “The Price of Inequity,” by Joseph Stiglitz. It’s a book that sensitizes the reader to the underlying causes of poverty in our society. Among those causes is the political and financial clout of organizations like Citigroup.

So with Stiglitz's book and inequity on my mind, I thought that it might be instructive and add perspective to see what the CEO of Citigroup makes in a year.

Turns out in 2012, the last year for which figures are available, CEO Michael Corbat was compensated to the tune of $11.5 million. I think it fair to assume, given the bloated nature of executive compensation, that last year he topped $12 million (we'll know in the next few days).

Now go back to that the Neediest Cases Fund TOTAL of nearly $6 million. It is about half Corbat's entire compensation for one year. Makes one wonder that Corbat contributed to Citigroup’s $77,000.

Interestingly, the Times story didn’t include the comparison of Corbat’s compensation with Citigroup’s "Neediest" contribution or with the total amount of money raise by the Times campaign. (Could the omission have something to do with what top executives at the Times make?)

Such comparisons would provide insight into why the pressing needs of this nation’s neediest are going unmet,  and why the Times effort, as worthy as it is, represents a token effort. The real solution lies in addressing inequity, greed and concentrated political power, as Stiglitz points out.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Thursday, March 10, 2011

Getting by on $100,000

Prepare yourselves. I’m about to propose something un-American, anti-free market, and anti-individualistic.

You have now been warned and, I hope, immunized. You will not react to the following by saying “Why that’s utterly un-American! etc.”

Ready? Here we go....

In America, starting now, no person will be compensated more than $100,000 a year.

That’s enough, already.

With that lid comes universal health care, no income taxes (with one exception—see below), an adequate pension, the best schools in the world and guaranteed food and decent housing for all. There will be so little crime, the nation will be down to two or three prisons.

We might even see such a shift in values that we will disband our military, saving trillions of dollars and thousands of lives.

Starting today, your financial compensation and your perceived or proclaimed “worth” are separate concepts. You aren’t paid what you have been told you were “worth.” Your worth yesterday was what some kept “compensation” firm or over-paid board of directors told you that you were “worth.”

Today, your pay can not exceed $100,000. If, like many well-to-do, you get your kicks by being told that you are “worth” millions more than the next executive or hedge fund manager, you can still be told that. You just won’t be paid it.

To assuage your ego, I suggest a badging system like medals pinned on generals’ uniforms.

“My company has put my ‘worth’ at $50 million,” you can brag, pointing to your $50 million badge. Of course, you’ll look like a fool, but that’s your choice.

But, just to be clear, that so-called displayed “worth” is $49,900,000 more than your are actually paid, and everyone knows it.

In fact you are paid exactly what someone who is really “worth” $100,000 is paid.

Isn’t that unfair?

Not really, because the current “compensation” game is rigged and the executive market is grossly and dangerously inflated.

I contend that if you feel it is really important that you be paid 300 times what a line worker in your company is paid, or 3000 times what some off-shore worker is being paid by your company, you aren’t even “worth” $100,000. In fact, you might be worthless. A liability. The door is over there.

Some might even suggest that you morally bankrupt. I’ve even hear it said that you are insane. Delusional. Sociopathic.

So what happens to the difference between your alleged “worth” and your real compensation? That $49,900,000.

See those benefits above? The excess pays for them — for you and literally thousands of others. That’s right, thousands. Do the math.

“But I can’t get by on $100,000 a year,” you complain.

“Try it. You’ll like it.”

Say what?

Yes, you’ll live simply (and discover how much you don’t need), stop destroying the environment through overconsumption, be contributing to a more prosperous, equitable society, be helping thousands less fortunate than you (most will be making considerably less than $100,000 annually) and you and your corporation will no longer have a reason to rig the political system and make a sham of democracy.

You will also recognize just how important public services, equality and fairness are to you, your fellow executives and everyone else.

You owe that $50 million “worth” of yours to the nation’s infrastructure (now crumbling), its schools (now in crisis) and thousands of public workers (now having their rights taken from them) who keep the nation humming along so your company can afford your bloated “worth.”

Well, won’t this all contribute to a massive brain drain to other countries? Not if you keep your American citizenship. You may be paid abroad, but a “foreign earnings”
 tax kicks in. It claims everything over $100,000. Sorry.

If you can’t live with that, leave.

Won’t there be unintended consequences? Like empty mansions, plummeting Mercedes sales, and uneaten caviar. Absolutely.

It’s all part of living simply and fairly. It will mean getting rid of status symbols and discovering that life’s real gifts are available to all, even you.

Trust me, with time, you’ll get your values straight. You will even come to appreciate your own true value — as a human being.

Labels: , , , , ,

Wednesday, October 28, 2009

A just society as executive compensation

Tuesday, New York Times columnist David Brooks attacked the Obama administration for placing limits on executive compensation.

He called the effort a “fatal conceit” that is doomed to failure.

Brooks, and most who address this madness, overlook a key fact.

If lining their own pockets drives executives to their decisions, it stands to reason that the corporate decisions will be based on how much the executives can game the system to reward themselves.

The result: decisions that feed executive greed and to hell with the rest of us. We’ve seen plenty of those kinds of decisions recently. Hence the response of the Obama administration.

If there’s a problem with the government’s approach, it’s that it ignores the bankrupt values that drive the system.

We need leadership that makes decisions not for personal gain but for societal good.

By “good” I mean paying a living wage, offering meaningful work, providing universal health care, protecting the environment, providing affordable housing, maintaining justice and security, and educating children and adults alike.

Those are the rewards of leadership. Not vacation chalets in Aspen, yachts in Barbados, mansions in Scarsdale, private jets at the ready, country clubs, penthouses and jewels.

And certainly not compensation that is 500 times that of the average worker.

No, the rewards for the powerful should be nothing more than this: a modest, adequate salary with basic benefits and the knowledge that one’s leadership has helped create of a better, more just, sustainable society.

Ultimately, it comes down to a question of values. Talk about fatal conceit. What do our corporate leaders believe in? Themselves and their personal wealth or humanity and the future of the planet?

The government must come up with a way to ensure that the latter, not the former, values prevail.

Labels: , , , ,

Wednesday, April 01, 2009

Hedge Hog "Hogwash" — Part II: What they do

Chris Clair’s rebuttal of my questioning the compensation and worth of hedge fund managers continues.

For those who would like to follow the thread back to its Red Electric origins, my initial post, which invited Chris to comment, is here.

Part I of his response is here. I'll post Part III later in the week.

Note: Chris, a friend, journalist and former student, has reported on the hedge fund industry for the past eight years. He lives and works in Chicago and is the managing editor of Reuters HedgeWorld.


PART II

So what are hedge fund managers doing to earn positive returns? The best and brightest hedge fund managers exploit price inefficiencies in the market. They bet against securities (stocks, bonds and their derivatives) they believe are overvalued and buy securities they believe are underpriced or that have growth potential. Different managers do this in different ways and employ varying degrees of risk. Some funds are very low-risk and are designed to provide steady, incremental returns – say, 10% to 15% per year – in all market conditions (whether stocks are way up, way down or flat). Some funds use lots of leverage (borrowed money) to increase returns, or trade in complex securities that few understand, thereby raising the level of risk. The type of strategy any particular hedge fund follows and its riskiness is outlined in its offering documents.

Speaking of offering documents, I have to digress for a second here to talk about the “gambling” issue. Rick, you wrote, “Then there’s the question of whether the top 25 actually did anything to “earn” their largesse besides gamble with other people’s money.” Hedge funds invest money on behalf of other investors, but most hedge fund managers also place their own money in the funds they manage. In fact, outside investors often won’t even consider a relationship with a hedge fund manager that does not place a substantial amount of his or her own net worth in the funds that manager runs. It’s about alignment of interests. So while the managers are investing other people’s money, they are also investing their own money.

Additionally, it's not like the hedge fund managers stole the money they invest from somewhere; when the system works correctly, investors conduct extensive due diligence on managers and make a careful and conscious decision to gamble their own money. It's up to the investor to understand what he or she is investing in. Caveat emptor!

If one wants a risk-free investment, one should buy Treasury bills or open a savings account. Historically - like over the past 100 years – stocks have returned about 11% annually and bonds something less than that. When you experience years like we had in the 90s, (between 1990 and 1999 the average annual return of the U.S. stock market was nearly double what it was from 1926 through 1999), and the same in the middle part of this decade, you can bet there's going to be a reversion to the mean. In other words, people who got in at the end are going to lose money, at least in the short term.

Instead we seem to keep buying into the notion that every time we enter a bull market, it's a "new paradigm" and the "old rules" don't apply. That's just stupidity. So of course any investment in the stock market or anything else (even Treasuries when you get right down to it) carries the risk of loss. Hell, stuffing money in your mattress carries the risk of loss (fire, flood) but without any possibility of earning a positive return.

The hedge fund manager’s job is to earn money in all markets – to be smart enough to avail himself or herself of all the investment tools at his or her disposal to earn investors a positive return no matter what. Historically, the good ones have done that, which is why they can get away with charging higher fees. In the process they have helped boost university endowment returns and protected workers’ pensions. Even last year, the worst year on record for hedge funds (the average fund was down 19%) they still performed only half as bad as the stock market. And since the bulk of a hedge fund manager’s compensation comes from the performance fee, when a hedge fund manager loses money he gives up most of his or her income. And not just for that year, either. Most hedge funds have what are known as “high water marks,” whereby the manager must make up all that he has lost and then some before he can begin collecting the performance fee again. After 2008’s debacle, some hedge fund managers may not collect performance fees this year or next year.

I make that point simply to illustrate that not all hedge fund managers are John Paulson or George Soros, that some of them are essentially small businessmen and that they also face the same risk of loss as their investors.

Labels: , , , ,

Monday, March 30, 2009

Hedge Hog "Hogwash" — Part I: Contributions

Chris Clair, friend, journalist and former student, has reported on hedge funds and the financial industry for eight years. He lives and works in Chicago and is the managing editor of Reuters HedgeWorld.

I invited him to respond to my recent post, "Top Hedge Hogs of 2008." He has been kind enough to do so.

As you will see, he takes serious exception to my suggestion that hedge fund managers don’t earn their keep. I’ll run his response in three parts over the next few days.

Thanks, Chris, for taking the time to share your observations.

PART I

The quick and dirty response to your observation, "By comparison to most American workers, hedge fund managers contribute zilch and should be paid accordingly," is “hogwash.” The devil is in the details, however, so let’s get into some.

There are probably 4,000 or 5,000 hedge fund managers in the world, give or take a thousand. To say none of them contribute anything casts the net too wide. One can examine a sample of 4,000 or 5,000 anything – waitresses, teachers, nurses, policemen, construction workers, politicians, journalists – and find a certain percentage who don’t appear to contribute to the economy or to society, or who don’t contribute on a par with what they earn.

If you ask which bothers me more – knowing John Paulson earned $2.8 billion or knowing a half-dozen politically-connected trucking firms were paid millions of dollars by the city of Chicago for doing nothing – my answer is the trucking scandal, hands-down. John Paulson’s salary in and of itself doesn’t affect me. Having my tax dollars wasted affects me – by misallocating resources and depriving worthy and necessary projects the funds they need. And in fact, although there is a strong argument to be made that John Paulson does not pay enough in taxes on his income, at least he pays some taxes. Government waste squanders money and actually is a negative contribution to society and to the economy.

Two questions I see contained in your “Hedge Hogs” post, Rick, are “What does it mean to contribute?” and “How much money is ‘too much?’”

I’ll discuss later some ways hedge fund managers earn their money (and make money for their investors) and this notion of “too much.” For now I’ll focus on the contribution question. It’s true that hedge funds do not manufacture anything. But they do provide jobs, and not just jobs for traders with Ivy League business degrees. They hire analysts with economics degrees and clerical staff, for instance. These are good-paying jobs filled by people with all manner of experience, including some who don’t have the skills to work in construction or the temperament for teaching or the compassion to be a nurse. Hedge funds pay these employees good salaries – better than waitressing – and that money is in turn spent elsewhere.

The presence of hedge funds also means jobs for accountants, lawyers, traders in the pits at financial exchanges and others.

As other highly compensated people often do, hedge fund managers contribute money and time to philanthropic endeavors – charities, education and the arts. They do this for tax purposes, sure, but some of them also believe deeply in the causes they support. I know one manager who has plowed millions of dollars he’s made into a foundation he created that is dedicated to funding organizations that prevent child abuse and treat abused children. Another manager I know started a foundation to provide prosthetic limbs, and training on how to use them, to children in third-world countries. Neither of these managers can be found in that top-25 earners list published by Alpha.

It’s not how much one makes that matters, but what one does with the money one earns.

But where does this money come from? One might posit that the cost to society and the economy of the hedge fund managers’ strategies outweighs the contributions those managers make through their hiring, trading and philanthropic work. (By the way, I don’t consider criminals like Bernie Madoff to be hedge fund managers. They are con men, and if they hadn’t been running hedge fund cons they would have been swindling people some other way.)

To start with, it helps to understand how these guys get paid. Hedge fund managers make money from fees they charge investors. Hedge funds are restricted to investors who meet certain income/investable asset guidelines. You or I could not invest in them. Also hedge funds can't advertise like mutual funds can

Fund managers typically charge two kinds of fees: a straight management fee, usually 2% to 5%, that is based on the amount of assets they manage, and a performance or incentive fee, usually about 20% of whatever positive return they generate. A manager running a $100 million fund who earns a 15% return over 12 months, will, at the end of the year, collect between $2.3 million to $5.75 million from the management fee and another $3 million from the incentive fee.

It sounds like a lot of money, and compared to $50,000 or even $100,000, it is. However out of that pool of money the manager also must pay his or her employees their salaries and benefits, as well as office rent, brokerage fees, legal fees, accounting fees, etc. Some say hedge fund fees are too high and investors are being gouged. But hedge fund managers are paid what the market will bear. Investors know the fees going in and agree to pay them.

Most hedge fund managers manage between $100 million and $1 billion in assets. The people on Alpha’s list are those operating in rarefied air, people who have built enormous operations employing hundreds or thousands of people, or who have made exceptional bets and been right.

For Part II, What Hedge Fund managers actually do, go HERE.

Labels: , , , ,

Wednesday, February 04, 2009

A $300,000/year compensation cap for all

I hope that those who read the quote by James F. Reda in today’s New York Times recognize Reda’s words as representing a huge part of the problem facing this country.

Reda, the founder and *managing director of James F. Reda & and Associates, a compensation consulting firm, was asked what he thought of the Obama Administration’s plan to place a $500,000 cap on compensation to executives at companies receiving federal bailout money.

He responded:

“That is pretty draconian, $500,000 is not a lot of money, particularly if there is no bonus…And you know these companies that are in trouble are not going to pay much of an annual dividend.”

I don’t know about you, but to me $500,000 is absolutely a lot of money. It is more than 10 times what the average worker makes. Make that “made.”

Annual compensation of a half million dollars is “not a lot of money” only to the few, powerful and self-indulgent living in a world of Riviera mansions, Aspen ski chalets, private jets and pearl-handled toilet plungers.

The article lists some of them. Kenneth D. Lewis, head of the hat-in-hand Bank of America, took home more than $20 million in 2007. The clearly clueless Richard Wagoner, head of GM, raked in $14.4 million. (Don’t get me started on college football coaches and NBA point guards.)

A story in last Friday’s New York Times tells us that in 2006 (the last year for which the figures are available) the 400 wealthiest Americans made, ON AVERAGE…are you ready for this?…$263 million.

That’s on average in one year.

The motives, wisdom and competence of those allowing themselves to be paid so lavishly should immediately be suspect.

They have lost touch with reality — yours, mine and that of the vast majority of Americans.

So let’s just put it out there—and, Mr. President, note that I am reducing your cap number here. It means a cut of $100,000 in your own presidential salary of $400,000.

Bailout money aside, no one should be compensated at a rate of more than $300,000 a year. That’s enough. Actually that’s more than enough, as 98 out of 100 know, but we have to start somewhere.

If a company has more money available for executive compensation, it should rework its numbers. The money should used to raise the wages of everyone else, starting at the bottom — from the secretaries to the janitors, to assembly-line workers to the accounting clerks and sales staff.

As for James F. Reda — fire him.

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, November 12, 2008

CEO/worker Inequity short-circuits Circuit City

Time to do the ratio of CEO compensation to the pay of in-the-trenches sales clerks at Circuit City.

The national retailer has been so brilliantly managed by its top brass that it just declared bankruptcy.

The bankruptcy, of course, means that thousands of sales staffers soon will be on the streets while the golden parachutes unfurl for top management.

So what's that ratio?

Bloomberg.com reported earlier this year that in fiscal 2006 Circuit City’s CEO Philip Schoonover was paid $8.52 million including a salary of $975,000.

To cut costs last year, Schoonover and management fired more than 3,000 “overpaid” floor sales people who were making a whopping $11 per hour. Management replaced them with inexperienced new hires being paid $8 per.

Morale immediately tanked as did sales, but at least management didn’t do the unthinkable — cut Schoonover’s stratospheric compensation.

So what’s the ratio of Schoonover’s take to that of a floor salesperson, who we’ll figure averages $9/hour or $18,720 a year?

The management is rewarding Schoonover with 456 times as much as the average sales stiff.

To experience why workers might be embittered, Mr. Schoonover ought to try living for a year on $18,720, which is what Schoonover makes in roughly five hours.

I have maintained that any executive demanding or accepting pay of more than six or seven times what the average worker earns is in business strictly for the money. Workers, customers and shareholders be damned.

As the government ladles out billions to corporate American, the money should be conditioned on barring greed from corporate executive offices.

Labels: , ,

Monday, October 13, 2008

Greed-free management needed

As long as CEOs and Wall Street moguls are motivated by stratospheric personal aggrandizement (otherwise known as "greed"), the economy and financial system of this country are going to be in deep trouble.

When greed motivates decision-makers, decisions are, by definition, corrupt and immoral, and the powerless will lose.

Any execution of the new federal bailout plan that doesn’t adequately address exorbitant executive and boardroom compensation is bound to fail.

Nor should “reform” tie executive compensation to stock performance or profitability. Instead the measure of management success should be the welfare of workers and customers.

For starters, no executive should be compensated at a rate greater that eight times that of the lowest paid worker affected by that executive’s management decisions.

Appallingly, the current ratio is on the order of 350 to 1.

Do the math. If the lowest paid worker makes $30,000, the average CEO’s compensation (including stock options and retirement packages) is $10.5 million a year.

Think of it: The boss arrogantly manages a system that places an executive's “worth” at 350 times that of the worker on whom the corporation depends.

Such an attitude should be grounds not for reward but for dismissal and public shame.

Labels: ,

Monday, June 30, 2008

Showing greed the door

I have this absurd fantasy of being elected to Congress to replace our underwhelming representative, Democrat David Wu.

There I am in my office and the lobbyists are lined up to make their get-acquainted pitches.

I’d follow a mental script that I would read to every one of them.

“Nice to meet you. How much does your CEO make? And, by the way, how much do you make?"

Or, in the case of industrial groups or trade unions, I’d ask, “What is the average compensation for your chief executive or union president?

“Don’t know? Come back when you do. Oh, and when you do return, bring the compensation of the lowest paid worker in your company, trade group or union.”

“By the way, you can save yourself some time setting up a new appointment. Run the two numbers through a calculator. Divide the CEO compensation (and your own compensation) number by the lowest pay and if it comes to more than 10, you needn’t call because we will know that your industry/company/trade group/union's leadership is essentially motivated by greed.

"I’m sure you agree that our government has more important business than promoting greed.”

(Example of greed: the lowest paid worker makes $30,000 and the CEO makes $3 million, which is common, unfortunately. The ratio is—ready?—one to 100. Under my "times ten" rule, if the CEO wants $3 million in compensation, the lowest paid worker get $300,000. Now that's a minimum wage law! Here's another example. Under the "times ten rule" if the lowest paid worker gets $50,000, the CEO gets $500,000 — tops. That seems to me to be beyond fair compensation.)

Back to my D.C. office chat. “One more thing," I'd say, "don’t tell me that competition for these stuffed shirts (I'd probably use the term 'executive talent') forces you to pay CEOs mega-bucks. If they are so smart, why has the economy tanked? One reason is grotesque income inequity.”

I would organize a caucus of like-minded Congressional members who would join me in putting lobbyists through the same drill. Call us the "Ten Times or Less" caucus.

By the way, in my own Congressional office I’d make sure my staff salaries fell well within these parameters. Members of Congress are paid $169,300. I’d use a one-to-three ratio. The lowest pay would be roughly $57,000.

David (and Earl and Peter and Greg), are you listening?

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, March 28, 2007

Intel CEO "worth" 123.6 teachers

Here's today's Red Electric episode on "This American Life."

Today's Oregonian brings news that Intel's CEO Paul Otellini was "penalized" monetarily last year for the company's poor financial performance and for not meeting goals. In 2006, net income for Intel was down 42 percent over 2005.

Being "penalized" meant that in 2206 Otellini eked by on a mere $6.18 million in compensation. The AP story demonstrates the utter cruelty of Intel's decision by comparing Otellini's pittance to the $16.1 million raked in by CEO Hector Ruiz of Advanced Micro Devices.

The connection? AMD is Intel's chief rival.

Oh.

Now for the real comparison beyond the corporate bubble of competitive CEO "worth."

If you take Otellini's pauper's salary and divide it by $50,000, the wage a school district might pay a moderately experienced school teacher, you discover that Otellini, by American society's twisted market standard, is "worth" 123.6 teachers. Count slowly to 123 to get a full sense of the number. "One teacher...two teacher...etc."

Consider that 123 teachers are probably enough to staff five or six neighborhood elementary schools in Portland. You know, just like the ones the Portland School District has been closing.

Do the numbers on Ruiz's grotesque AMD compensation and you could probably throw in teachers for a couple of middle schools and a high school, as well as custodians to clean up after the kids.

Meanwhile, back at Intel and AMD, as they crunch the performance numbers and compare salaries, do Otellini, Ruiz and their compensation committee members ever weigh the debt—educational or financial—they owe teachers who helped them in their own lives?

One more note: Deep in The Oregonian story we get one more insight into Intel: Last September Intel's executives, while wringing their hands over up-coming compensation "penalties," announced they were eliminating 10,500 jobs world-wide.

I've raised this before, but it bears repeating: Let's hope that one day (soon!) folks will look back at this time as a shameful aberration—that they will have ensured that such greed and inequity will never happen again.

Labels: , , , ,